Best flour for pie crust

Best Flour for Pie Crust: All-Purpose vs Pastry Flour Explained

Last Updated on November 12, 2026

The 30-Second Answer: the best flour for pie crust is unbleached all-purpose flour for a flaky, sturdy crust that is easy to roll, or pastry flour for a more tender, delicate crust. Many bakers blend the two.

  1. Most reliable: all-purpose flour (about 10 to 12% protein).
  2. Most tender: pastry flour (about 8 to 9% protein).
  3. Easy DIY pastry flour: mix equal weights of all-purpose and cake flour.

Flour matters, but cold fat and minimal mixing matter more. See flaky crust tips.

A note on this guide: Reviewing a product properly is not easy, and real testing takes time. For now, this guide is research-based, built on manufacturer specs, product details and verified owner feedback. Our team is testing these products in The Kitchenware Journal lab, and we will update this guide with our hands-on results and photos very soon.

Pie crust is a balance between tenderness and structure. Too much gluten and the crust turns tough and shrinks in the pan; too little and it tears when you roll it and slumps in the oven. Protein content in flour controls how much gluten can form.

This guide compares the main flours for pie crust, shows which to use for each kind of pie, and lists the flours and tools that make good crusts easier.

Flour Types Compared for Pie Crust

FlourTypical proteinCrust resultBest for
Pastry flourAbout 8 to 9%Very tender, delicateSingle-crust custard and cream pies, tarts
All-purpose flourAbout 10 to 12%Flaky, sturdy, easy to rollMost pies, double crusts, fruit pies
AP + cake flour (1:1)About 9%Tender, still workablePastry flour substitute
Cake flourAbout 7 to 8%Crumbly, fragileBlending only
Whole wheat pastry flourAbout 9 to 10%Nutty, tender, more rusticRustic pies, galettes
Bread flourAbout 12 to 14%Tough, chewy, shrinksNot recommended

Protein varies by brand; check the bag or brand website.

Which Flour for Which Pie?

  • Apple, cherry and berry pies: all-purpose flour supports juicy fillings and lattice tops.
  • Pumpkin, custard and cream pies: pastry flour or an AP and pastry blend for a tender bite.
  • Hand pies and pot pies: all-purpose for strength. See how to make pie crust for pot pie.
  • Galettes: all-purpose or whole wheat pastry flour for rustic flavor.
  • Gluten-free: use a 1:1 gluten-free baking blend with xanthan gum, and chill the dough well.

Best Flours and Tools for Pie Crust

1. King Arthur Organic All-Purpose Flour, Unbleached, 5 lb (Best All-Purpose Flour)

King Arthur, Organic 100% All-Purpose Flour, Unbleached, 5 lb Bag - Non-GMO Project Verified, No Preservatives

King Arthur’s unbleached organic all-purpose flour.

Why We Like It

Consistent protein from batch to batch, which makes crusts predictable.

Flaws to Know

  • Higher protein than some AP flours; handle gently
  • Bag size may be large for occasional bakers

Buy it if: you want one flour for every pie. Skip it if: you want the most tender crust possible.

Buy on Amazon

2. Unpretentious Pastry Flour (Best Pastry Flour)

Unpretentious Pastry Flour, Non-GMO, Great For Flaky Pastries, Pies, Muffins, Biscuits (20 Pound)

A non-GMO pastry flour sold for flaky pastries.

Why We Like It

Lower protein for a tender, melt-in-the-mouth crust.

Flaws to Know

  • Larger pack size and price
  • Softer dough tears more easily

Buy it if: you bake custard and cream pies. Skip it if: you make lattice fruit pies.

Buy on Amazon

3. Dominique Ansel Pastry Flour, French T55 (Best French-Style Flour)

Dominique Ansel Pastry Flour, Finely Milled French T55, Crepes etc. 1.65lb

A finely milled French T55 pastry flour.

Why We Like It

A fine, soft flour suited to tarts and pâte brisée.

Flaws to Know

  • Pricier than domestic flours
  • Small bag

Buy it if: you bake French tarts. Skip it if: you bake in bulk.

Buy on Amazon

4. 365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Whole Wheat Pastry Flour (Best Whole Wheat Option)

365 by Whole Foods Market, Organic Whole Wheat Pastry Flour, 2 LB

Organic whole wheat pastry flour milled from soft wheat.

Why We Like It

Adds nutty flavor with less toughness than regular whole wheat flour.

Flaws to Know

  • Darker, more rustic crust
  • Shorter shelf life; store cool

Buy it if: you want whole grain in your crust. Skip it if: you want a classic pale crust.

Buy on Amazon

5. Spring Chef Large Dough Blender (Best Pastry Blender)

Spring Chef Large Dough Blender For Baking - Durable Pastry Blender - Black | Heavy Duty Dough Mixer Hand Tool w/ Stainless Steel Blades, Professional Pastry Cutter Tool for Easy Mixing, Dishwasher Safe

A large pastry (dough) blender for cutting fat into flour.

Why We Like It

Keeps butter cold by limiting hand contact, for flakier layers.

Flaws to Know

  • Another tool to store
  • Slower than a food processor for big batches

Buy it if: you mix crust by hand. Skip it if: you use a food processor.

Buy on Amazon

6. Pyrex Deep 9.5-Inch Glass Pie Plate, 2-Pack (Best Pie Plates)

Pyrex Deep 2-Pack (9.5') Glass Baking Dish Set, Round Pie Glass Bakeware | Dishwasher, microwave, freezer & preheated oven safe

Two 9.5-inch glass pie dishes: one deep and one with easy-grab handles.

Why We Like It

Glass lets you check the bottom crust for browning.

Flaws to Know

  • Glass heats slower than metal
  • Avoid sudden temperature changes

Buy it if: you want to see when the bottom is done. Skip it if: you want the fastest browning.

Buy on Amazon

7. Anchor Hocking Oven Basics 9.5-Inch Deep Pie Plate (Best Budget Pie Plate)

Anchor Hocking Oven Basics 9.5-Inch Deep Pie Plate, Clear, 1 Piece

A tempered glass deep pie plate, safe in the microwave, preheated oven, fridge, freezer and dishwasher.

Why We Like It

A cheap, deep dish for tall fruit pies.

Flaws to Know

  • Single plate, no lid
  • Glass can break if dropped

Buy it if: you want a basic deep dish. Skip it if: you want a decorative plate.

Buy on Amazon

Tips for a Flaky Pie Crust

  1. Weigh flour for consistency; scooping can add too much. Use the King Arthur ingredient weight chart.
  2. Keep butter, water and even flour cold.
  3. Leave pea-size pieces of butter; they create flaky layers.
  4. Add ice water a tablespoon at a time, just until the dough holds.
  5. Rest the dough in the fridge at least 1 hour to relax gluten.
  6. Chill the shaped crust before baking to reduce shrinking.

Related guides: cake flour or bread flour, how to make cake flour, flour substitutes for baking and baking equipment.

UK, Canada and EU Flour Equivalents

  • UK and Ireland: use plain flour for pastry. “Pastry flour” is uncommon; a soft plain flour works well.
  • Canada: Canadian all-purpose flour often runs higher in protein; some bakers use pastry flour or add a little cake flour.
  • Germany: Type 405 (Weizenmehl Type 405) for tender pastry, Type 550 for sturdier crusts.
  • France: T45 or T55 (farine T55 is classic for pâte brisée).
  • Italy: type 00 or 0 (farina 00). Spain: harina de repostería or harina floja.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best flour for pie crust?

Unbleached all-purpose flour for most pies; pastry flour for the most tender crust.

Can I use bread flour for pie crust?

It is not recommended; the high protein makes a tough crust that shrinks.

Is pastry flour the same as cake flour?

No. Pastry flour has slightly more protein than cake flour.

How do I make pastry flour at home?

Mix equal weights of all-purpose flour and cake flour.

Does bleached flour make a better crust?

Bleached flour can be slightly more tender, but unbleached works well and has better flavor for many bakers.

Samantha Hickel, Kitchenware Reviewer and Cookware Expert

Reviewed by Samantha Hickel, Kitchenware Reviewer & Cookware Expert. Samantha has cooked for more than ten years, has reviewed kitchenware for The Kitchenware Journal since 2022, and covers stock pots, saucepans, canning, cake and bread pans, cutting boards and everyday kitchen tools. Our lab tests kitchenware, cutting boards and serving pieces for capacity, durability, stain resistance and ease of care. How we test.

Related guides: How to Make Pie Crust for Pot Pie · Cake Flour or Bread Flour · How to Make Cake Flour · Flour Substitutes for Baking

Scroll to Top